If You’re in a Creative Rut, Check Your Nervous System

A new book woke me up the other night. Photo evidence of the too-early wake-up below.

It was three o'clock in the morning, exactly one week after I sent my novel, I'm Keeping the Dog off for copy editing, and suddenly a new character emerged while I should have been dreaming. My brain whispered…then she got louder. I tried to roll over and pull the covers up to my chin. I had to be up in a couple hours to get the kids ready for school. I needed sleep. Then, my brain yelled.

I got out of bed, pressed start on the coffee pot I'd had the presence of mind to set up the night before, and went to my computer. I started with an outline. Then a logline.

Ten years after Maya's husband deleted her novel and silenced her writing, she realizes that helping her artistic daughter pursue her dreams will require her to reclaim her own, even if it means ending her marriage.

I thought I was getting up just to capture the idea in an outline. But then I found myself moving from outline directly into drafting. Now, I can't seem to stop.

The funny thing is, I'm Keeping the Dog came to me the same way. In the middle of the night with enough force to pull me out of bed and send me to the computer. My stories have no respect for business hours and I couldn't be more grateful. Seriously.

That spark, and the dopamine rush that follows, are a gift I don't take for granted.

Because there was a time when waking up at three am looked very different.

What Used to Meet Me in the Dark

Not long ago I used to wake because of stress, trauma, rumination.

My heart would race. My mind sprinting, replaying conversations, anticipating problems, trying to solve things that I had no business solving for other people. Sometimes I knew what triggered it, but often I didn't. I'd wake with a sense of foreboding, my body sounding an alarm without bothering to point at the fire I was supposed to be running from.

During those years there was no room for a character to step forward and start telling me their story because my brain awas already occupied by hypervigilance and a desperate attempt to close the loops of stress I didn't understand.

In fact, I have a novel I started during those years and haven't finished because the characters went silent. I have two nonfiction books that I started and stopped as well. They're locked in the vault of my Google Drive without a way out.

The reason I stopped has nothing to do with ability or creativity. It also has nothing to do with writer's block. During that time I wrote 24 books for other people. Books that didn't require me to do any emotional labor. I have the infrastructure in Connected Ghostwriting to write, edit, proofread, format, and even self-publish all of my books sitting locked in my Google Drive.

Sometimes a Creative Block Isn't About Creativity

When we're in a creative rut we tend to personalize it.

We're lazy. We need more willpower. We've never been good at finishing what we start. We lost our creative juices. We stare at the blank page and it becomes evidence in a trial to prove our failure.

We pile shame on top of exhaustion and expect the combination to produce something wonderful.

Spoiler alert: it doesn't.

For a long time I treated creativity as a brain issue. If I couldn't write I needed a better idea, more discipline, a better routine, fewer distractions. I even considered medicating my ADHD for the first time since my twenties. I thought the problem was my brain.

The trouble is, you can't shame your body into a safe space where creativity can find you.

Creativity doesn't live only in our minds, we create it with our whole selves. In fact, neurocognitive researchers have found that in creativity our problem solving network and our daydreaming networks work together—something that almost never happens with other brain functions. Creativity is energy and if we're using energy to brace, scan, protect, and survive a life that's slowly eroding our being there might not be much energy left.

Creativity needs curiosity, it needs space, it needs experimentation, openness, connections, risk-taking, authenticity, and a loose grip on the control wheel.

To understand what happened to our creativity we have to ask: How does chronic stress and trauma affect these components?

Stress and trauma cause you to fold inward—I call this turtling—pulling into my shell to protect myself from the world. Unfortunately, this is the opposite of space.

When you're in protection mode the risk-taking associated with experimenting feels too vulnerable. What if you put your creativity into something and it doesn't work out? Your brain will spin on that loop for hours and convince yourself not to even try.

Protection mode keeps others out—connection required for creative spark becomes impossible. Cue more turtling.

And authenticity? While I was in the thick of my creativity desert I wrote some, but none of it lit me up, and all of it felt like pulling teeth. None of it was authentic. None of it makes me proud.

When your nervous system is under threat, control can feel like the only thing keeping you safe. This is true whether the threat is emotional, relational, financial, something that happened a long time ago that your amygdala can't let go of, or a bear currently chasing you through your home office. (I could pile all the research in here, but I placed a list at the end of the article for those of you who want a nerdy-deep dive.)

Your nervous system doesn't care about your word count or content calendar or how many unfinished manuscripts sit on your desktop. It's trying to protect you and taking time for all the things creativity requires means you have to put down the armor.

Protection can look like a lot of different things.

  • anxiety

  • procrastination (my favorite is chore-crastination where I find all sorts of household chores to do instead of writing).

  • perfectionism

  • numbness

  • exhaustion

  • irritability

  • lack of focus

We personalize it and call ourselves lazy because that makes us feel like we're actually in control of it. The trouble is, you can't shame your body into a safe space where creativity can find you.

Rumination Vs. Imagination

Stress and inspiration look surprisingly similar from a distance (so do nervousness and excitement, but that's a different article).

Both can wake you up.

Set your heart racing.

Jet-propel your thoughts.

Create urgency - you must get up and do the thing NOW!

But, if you get closer you see the difference, and if, you tune into your body you'll notice they feel different.

Rumination is a set of interconnected circles that constrict, contract, and convince you to be smaller in thought, in heart, and in body. It repeats the same questions trying to produce certainty.

Imagination travels, expands your thinking and your emotional range, and moves you toward a goal. Imagination tells you to grow. It asks "What next?" over and over.

When I'm Keeping The Dog and The Words She Kept woke me, I wasn't trapped in a loop. I was following a thread. One thought lead to another. Maya sitting at her computer led me to her daughter. Her daughter's creativity led me to the dream Maya had let die. That dream led me to the central premise of the book: Leaving a marriage is not always the destruction of a family; sometimes it is how a mother ends an inheritance of silence.

I wasn't trying to escape. I was joyfully following the thread. I was playing.

The only thing that changed in the months prior to these sparks was the state of my nervous system.

Before You Blame Yourself, Check on Your Nervous System

If you are in a creative rut your first instinct may be to reach for a new productivity system. Get up earlier, buy a new notebook, create strict deadlines, give yourself a sticker chart.

But maybe rigidity is the whole problem. Maybe control is keeping you from joyfully embracing creative flow.

Some questions to consider:

  • What was happening in my life when creating became difficult?

  • Am I uninspired or overwhelmed?

  • What happens in my body when I sit down to create?

  • Am I afraid of doing this badly or am I afraid of doing it honestly?

  • Whose reaction am I scared of?

  • Have I left any room in my life for curiosity or does every minute of my life have a purpose?

Don't turn these questions into another assignment, they're meant to spark a noticing so you can start small and invite space for creativity back in.

Then, give yourself time to daydream. Creativity requires you to be open to new ideas and inspiration. (Julia Cameron's The Artist's Way does this better than I can explain in this article… link at the end.)

Take a walk without trying to turn it into time to write in your brain, just notice the world and walk down a street you don't normally turn on.

Sit outside and draw.

Make something you'll never monetize.

Write a scathing letter to the person you're worried about upsetting with your writing and then burn it (this is a personal favorite).

And, if your body and nervous system are holding more than you can work through on your own, invite in support. In the past months I've called on friends, colleagues, therapists, and a coach to help me shake things off. And, I have two clients right now who are doing this work with me in my coaching program.

The goal is to build a relationship with your body and mind that doesn't require creativity to fight for the scraps of energy left after survival takes it's fill.

Your Creativity May Be Resting, Not Gone

A quiet season for creativity doesn't mean your gift is gone forever. I once stopped writing for nine years while living in survival mode. I didn't start again until a neuromuscular condition paralyzed me and forced me to be still and quiet enough for my imagination to come back online. This most recent bout of creative downturn was similar—but thankfully I didn't need paralysis to shake me out of it.

Sometimes your imagination retreats because you're carrying too much.

Rest without having to earn it.

Make something that isn't useful.

Spend time with music, books, museums, and people that bring you back to yourself. Laugh with abandon.

Creativity responds to attention, permission and room to play, and curiosity, not to punishment.

Want the science behind the creativity/nervous system link? Here are some of my favorite resources (because I'm a total nerd).

Cameron, J. (1992). The Artist's Way: A spiritual path to higher creativity. Jeremy P. Tarcher/Putnam.

David, S. (2016). Emotional agility: Get unstuck, embrace change, and thrive in work and life (S. David, Narr.) [Audiobook]. Penguin Audio

Smith, J. (2022). Why has nobody told me this before? HarperCollins.

Weir, K. (2022, April 1). The science behind creativity. Monitor on Psychology, 53(3), 40. https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/04/cover-science-creativity

Xiaoyu Guo, Yifan Wang, Yuecui Kan, Jiaqi Zhang, Linden J. Ball, Haijun Duan, How does stress shape creativity? The mediating effect of stress hormones and cognitive flexibility, Thinking Skills and Creativity, Volume 52, 2024, 101521, ISSN 1871-1871, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tsc.2024.101521.

Zeng J, Meng J, Wang C, Leng W, Zhong X, Gong A, Bo S and Jiang C (2023) High vagally mediated resting-state heart rate variability is associated with superior working memory function. Front. Neurosci. 17:1119405. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2023.1119405

Previous
Previous

Give Space in Stories, Business, and Life

Next
Next

Books Should be Windows and Mirrors