Spinning Your Wheels Instead of Writing? Introducing Author Archetypes

I've had some version of the same conversation with aspiring authors more times than I can count.

"I want to write a book."

Great. What kind of book?

And then comes the look.

If we're on Zoom, this is usually the moment when their eyes drift slightly upward, as though the answer might be written somewhere on the ceiling behind their computer. Then I get some version of: "Well...it's sort of a business book. But there are personal stories in it. And I want it to be inspirational. But also practical. I have this framework I use with clients that I definitely want to include. And I think I want to talk about what happened to me when I was younger because that's really why I do this work in the first place. Oh, and maybe there's a workbook component?"

So. A business-self-help-memoir-workbook-manifesto.

Excellent.

This is actually one of my favorite parts of what we do at Connected Ghostwriting, because underneath all of that apparent confusion is usually something really good. The author isn't struggling because they have nothing to say. They're struggling because they have too much to say, and they haven't yet figured out which version of themselves needs to be driving the book.

Most aspiring authors think their first big decision is the subject of the book. I think there's often a decision that comes even earlier: Who are you going to be on the page?

Because you may be an expert, a storyteller, a teacher, a provocateur, a survivor, a strategist, a researcher, a business owner, a parent, a leader, and the person who has spent the last fifteen years quietly developing a brilliant system on the back of approximately 4,000 sticky notes. All of those things can be true. They just can't all fight for the microphone at the same time.

And that's where I've started thinking about author archetypes.

The Thought Leader

The Thought Leader has something to say about the way we think.

This is the person who comes into a conversation with an idea that has been bothering them, in the best possible way. They've noticed something other people aren't noticing. They think their industry is approaching a problem incorrectly. They're questioning an assumption everyone else seems to have accepted. Or they've spent years watching the same thing happen and have finally reached the point of saying, "Okay, can we please talk about this?"

Thought Leaders don't necessarily come to us saying, "I'm a thought leader," which is probably for the best because announcing yourself as a thought leader is a little like announcing that you're very humble. Usually, they say something more like, "I just think we're having the wrong conversation about this."

The Thought Leader's book is often driven by a thesis rather than a process. There's an argument underneath it. A perspective. A challenge to conventional wisdom. They want readers to finish the book seeing something differently than they did before.

Their biggest challenge is often deciding what belongs in the book. Thought Leaders tend to have ideas with tentacles. One thought connects to six others, which connects to a study they read eight years ago, which reminds them of a client story, which leads to another argument, and suddenly we have 93,000 words and are discussing whether Chapter Four needs its own book.

Sometimes it does, so we get to planning book 2.

The Storyteller

Then there's the Storyteller.

The Storyteller usually doesn't start with a framework. They start with something that happened.

A childhood. A loss. A marriage. A divorce. A career. A diagnosis. A business failure. A family secret. A reinvention. A person they loved. A place they escaped. A moment that split their life into before and after.

Sometimes they come to us with journals. Sometimes they have voice notes. Sometimes they have 200 pages they've already written. And sometimes they have nothing but memories and the certainty that those memories mean something.

The misconception is that a Storyteller simply needs to tell the story from beginning to end. Usually, no.

Your life happened chronologically. Your book doesn't necessarily have to. One of the most important questions we ask is not simply, "What happened?" It's "Why does what happened matter to the person reading it?"

Because the best story-driven books aren't just records of events. They create recognition. They make a reader think, Oh my God, someone else has felt this. They allow one person's very specific experience to illuminate something much more universal: grief, ambition, motherhood, identity, abuse, love, belonging, resilience, shame, success, faith, failure, starting over.

The Storyteller's danger is trying to include everything because everything actually happened. Unfortunately, reality is under no obligation to provide good narrative structure. That's our job.

The Methodologist

The Methodologist is one of my favorites because they often don't realize they have a book at all.

They'll say, "I don't know if I have enough to write about."

Then we start asking about their work.

"Well, when a client comes to me, first I have them do this."

Okay.

"And then there are really three things we look at."

Interesting.

"And I've found that if they skip the second stage, they almost always end up back where they started."

Excuse me?

"And then I have this model I created to explain it..."

Congratulations. You have been hiding a book from yourself.

The Methodologist has developed a way of doing something. Maybe it's formally named and trademarked and appears in a beautiful diagram. Maybe it currently lives in their brain and on a whiteboard that hasn't been erased since 2019. Either way, there is a repeatable process underneath their expertise.

Their book can turn that process into intellectual property.

These are often the coaches, consultants, therapists, executives, entrepreneurs, educators, and practitioners who have done something so many times that they no longer recognize how much they know. Their process feels obvious to them because they've been living inside it for years.

It is not obvious to everyone else. That's the book.

The challenge for the Methodologist is usually resisting the urge to teach everything. Readers do not need every single thing you know. They need enough of what you know, in the right order, to get somewhere useful.

The Blueprint Builder

I love a complicated hybrid: the Blueprint Builder.

This person is dangerous because they have both a framework and stories.

I say dangerous lovingly.

The Blueprint Builder doesn't only want to explain what to do. They want the reader to understand why it matters. They tend to move naturally between teaching and storytelling, between "Here's what I learned" and "Here's how you can use it."

Their personal experiences give the framework emotional weight, and the framework gives the stories practical usefulness. When it works, it works beautifully…even when, like my current client, we have to reorganize the book three times.

The problem is that Blueprint Builders are especially susceptible to the Everything Everywhere All at Once Book Problem.

They have a methodology. They have a personal story. They have client stories. They have exercises. They have research. They have a philosophy. They have a TED Talk hiding in Chapter Six. They have three other books hiding inside this book. And they want all of it.

This is often where a ghostwriter or book strategist earns their keep, not by supplying more ideas, but by helping the author decide which ideas belong here.

So which one are you?

Here's the part I want to emphasize: these aren't boxes.

You don't have to swear lifelong allegiance to one author archetype. A Thought Leader can tell deeply personal stories. A Storyteller can teach. A Methodologist can challenge conventional wisdom. And some of the strongest books deliberately blend multiple approaches.

The value of identifying your dominant archetype is that it gives you a center of gravity. When you know the role you're primarily playing for the reader, you can make better decisions about what belongs in the book.

Ask yourself: When someone closes my book, what do I most want to have happened?

Do I want them to think differently?

Do I want them to feel seen through my story?

Do I want them to understand and use my method?

Or do I want to combine story and strategy so they can actually build something different in their own lives or work?

And if your immediate reaction is, "Well, Maria, I want all four," welcome to my world.

That's probably why you need a book strategy in the first place. Because most of the people who come to us don't have a shortage of material. They have decades of experience, stories, frameworks, failures, observations, hard-won lessons, client transformations, half-finished Google Docs, old keynote presentations, journal entries, podcast transcripts, and approximately seventeen notes on their phone titled BOOK IDEA.

The problem isn't finding something to say. The work is discovering which book all of it is trying to become. And that brings us to another question entirely:

What type of book are you actually writing?

That's what I'll tackle in my next article.

Previous
Previous

But He Didn’t Hit You: A Call for Stories

Next
Next

Give Space in Stories, Business, and Life