Actual footage of a ghostwriter at work. (Kidding…there would need to be at least three beverages on the desk for this to be real.)
Today I got a manuscript back from my editor. It's a client's book - a prescriptive memoir. This book has consumed work hours for a year. I've restructured the entire thing three times. I've rewritten again and again. Today it came back with a total of two comments from the amazing Sue Toth.
Sue is not shy about edits. The last manuscript she sent back had 65 comments - the equivalent of being covered in red pen. So having this manuscript come back almost completely clean told me something.
Excessive editing and rewriting works.
I Started by Finding the Book's Real Shape
This book started out as a memoir, but then we quickly realized there was a framework hidden in the prose. We pulled the framework out to make it a trademarkable asset for the author. Then, we stuck the framework in the second half of the book after the memoir sections. This gave us another problem.
I Moved the Pieces Until the Story Made Sense
The transition from memoir to instruction felt abrupt. We invited some beta readers to give feedback, and they agreed. So, then I created a map of the story and overlaid the framework on the story. Then, I started an entirely new draft and started moving the teaching pieces into the memoir pieces, so we wound up with a chapter structure that is more like typical self-help (story, teaching, story wrap-up) but with a lot more story. This led to another problem.
I Cut What the Reader Didn't Need
Some of the ideas wound up repeating, so we did a round of edits just focused on cutting repetition.
I Followed Every Thread That Felt Unfinished
I reread the manuscript and left questions at any part where I needed more information from the author. Then, I interviewed her about those specific questions and used those notes to expand the narrative where appropriate.
I Read It Again as a Reader, Not the Writer
My final read-through was one where I didn't change much, save for a word here or there. I made sure the story flowed and that it was enjoyable to read.
I Let the Editor Show Me What I'd Missed
Sue's comments were spot on, and I made a few edits this morning before sending the manuscript to the author and publisher. Next steps are adding the acknowledgements and dedication and then sending it off to our formatter so it's ready for interior layout.
A Clean Manuscript Is Built One Revision at a Time
Two comments didn't mean the book had been easy to edit. They reflected all the work that happened before Sue ever opened the manuscript: reshaping the structure, listening to readers, asking better questions, and revising until the story and the framework felt like parts of the same book.
That kind of editing can feel excessive while you're in it. You move a section, reread the whole thing, and find another problem. You solve that one, and the book changes again. But each pass gave this manuscript a little more clarity and helped the author's ideas reach the reader.
A nearly clean manuscript isn't proof that every book needs endless revisions. It's a reminder that the right work, done with care and good collaborators, can make a complicated book feel clear. Today, two comments told me we'd gotten it there. It was worth it, even if I wanted to throw the manuscript out the window a few times.
Want support with your book? I work with authors through
Book coaching: One-on-one guidance to help you shape your idea, plan your book, and keep making progress.
Co-writing: We develop and write the book together, drawing on your expertise and voice.
Manuscript writing: I turn your ideas, interviews, notes, and experiences into a complete manuscript in your voice.
Editing: I help strengthen your manuscript's structure, clarity, flow, and language while preserving your voice.
Have a book in mind? Learn more at ConnectedGhostwriting.com or email me at maria@connectedghostwriting.com. You can also book a free consultation call here.